HomeTVChicago PD Season 10 Episode 3 Assessment: A Good Man

Chicago PD Season 10 Episode 3 Assessment: A Good Man

Saying goodbye to a fan-favorite character, particularly one which has been a part of the collection for the reason that starting, is rarely simple.

And with Chicago PD Season 10 Episode 3, solely the third installment into the season, that is what they did by giving Jesse Lee Soffer’s Jay Halstead a sendoff.

It is laborious to explain how we’re speculated to really feel about it, although.

Two issues might be true on the identical time. One, Jesse Lee Soffer gave us a really unimaginable efficiency all through the hour and was a pleasure to observe. And two, that sendoff was rushed and weird.

The information that Jesse Lee Soffer could be leaving had followers of the collection in utter shock, dismay, and denial.

The dearth of any data surrounding the character of the departure has solely fueled the hearth. We might by no means know the whys surrounding the exit; all we all know is the impression that it will go away on the collection and viewers.

However a departure of such a staple of the collection and one of many unique characters earlier than a midseason finale or finale is just uncommon. It is not often achieved for a cause.

It takes time to provide a staple character the sendoff they, the actor, and the followers deserve. It is one thing that needs to be deliberate properly and thought out.

There’s been an inflow of mind-boggling exits on primetime today, and it has been laborious to swallow. No, there isn’t any appeasing everybody, however a superb story is an efficient story.

As an everyday installment, the hour was action-packed and entertaining. The case was riveting, and it was laborious to take my eyes off the display screen with every little thing that transpired.

As a last installment for a beloved character (assuming that the open-ended shut would not result in visits), there isn’t any getting round how rushed the entire thing was.

That they had three installments to develop a storyline that will result in Halstead exiting the collection, leaving a job he loves behind, abandoning his place as Voight’s proper hand, and strolling away from a brand new marriage.

They usually did not feasibly give us sufficient to work inside these three installments. They crammed weeks price of buildup right into a single episode and shipped Halstead off to Bolivia by the top.

With extra time and respiration room, even when it wasn’t everybody’s cup of tea, they may’ve made this precise ending work by fleshing it out extra and maybe reaching this comparable conclusion by the midseason.

In spite of everything, we spent your entire first half of Chicago PD Season 9 watching Hailey’s descent into darkness and anxiousness over her actions in that season opener.

I did the precise factor when it counted. Did not I do this?


Halstead deserved that sort of time, and so did viewers.

As a result of it was a rushed hodgepodge of issues it felt like had been lacking items of the puzzle on Halstead’s headspace, how all of this caught as much as him, and the turning level he made in being a person who could not fathom returning to the army and was indignant at Mouse for his alternative, to mirroring it.

It felt like they borrowed bits and items from earlier plots. Halstead heading to some military unit as a result of the world is extra black and white, and that is what he wants — it is a precise reproduction of how Mouse exited the collection.

And perhaps it was an intentional callback meant to showcase how Halstead got here full circle with reaching that very same conclusion. One thing he did not perceive again then, he will get all too properly now, and there is an intention poetic impact to that.

Halstead loving Hailey however abruptly leaving her for a job alternative and for what’s greatest for him rips off Erin’s exit, which is unlucky contemplating the discourse through the years that led to parallels drawn between the 2 relationships all the time.

Halstead: One dangerous act would not make you a foul particular person. You and I each know that.
Hailey: What? Jay, can I discuss to you for a second? This is not you.
Halstead: What is not?
Hailey: Every part!

A minimum of Halstead’s exit wasn’t as terrible or out of character as Antonio’s, however the notion that Halstead did not need to turn into like Voight or quite did need to turn into him had tinges of Antonio’s descent in these final days.

If it wasn’t obvious how a lot of a rush job it was, the shortage of any last goodbyes between Halstead and the opposite staff members was jarring.

Credit score the place it is due; they at the least gave us a uncommon Halstead and Burgess scene early within the installment. You’ll be able to depend on one hand the quantity of these we have gotten in 10 years.

However it sucks that they drove the break up staff dynamic into the bottom, and it caught even for Halstead’s last moments. Why could not Halstead say goodbye to Burgess, Ruzek, or Atwater?

Why did not he get a second with Trudy, who’s just like the Den Mother of the squad and has private connections with all of them and would’ve had a assured, candy, emotional second?

Why did not Halstead get to say goodbye to his new mentee, Torres? A small scene of him giving the child some parting phrases would’ve been endearing and made for a beautiful passing of the torch second.

Why did Halstead present up at Chicago Med twice and nonetheless did not get a scene together with his brother?

They at the least supplied us with last moments with Hailey and Voight. However in doing so, it was obvious how usually these dynamics had been pitfalls.

Not as a result of they weren’t good ones, however as a result of Halstead obtained caught in a rotation with those self same two characters, and we missed out on a lot, and he suffered narratively due to it.

By now, it is no secret that this reviewer is not an Upstead shipper or was invested a lot in that relationship. However I sympathize with those that are and nonetheless admire wise storytelling.

Soffer and Spiradakos gave their all throughout that goodbye scene, and their feelings livened up the weird writing, however even with their greatest efforts, they could not make this make any sense.

It felt like they had been setting them up for a wedding that fizzled out or some type of breakup. Narratively, it in all probability would’ve made extra sense in the event that they caught with that.

Whether or not you loved the pairing or not, there have been so many unresolved points and communication issues between them that it felt like that ought to’ve gone someplace.

Prior to now couple of installments, the space between them was pronounced. Halstead had shut down on her fully. They usually merely by no means did something with that.

They might’ve spun it into one thing about them getting married too quickly or unpacked some trauma or no matter else. As a substitute, it simply went unaddressed.

Halstead informed her that she was the love of his life, they usually hadn’t ended their relationship. Nonetheless, he additionally basically emotionally manipulated her into agreeing that she ought to let him go if she actually liked him. He deserted her for an indeterminate period of time by leaving the nation that very same day.

Halstead: We’re doing it once more.
Voight: What?
Halstead: We’re doing it once more.
Voight: Hear, we do not have quite a lot of time. Now give me the knife.
Halstead: What the hell am I doing?

And he did that after he went to the Chief with out chatting with her about his plans and resigned with out a lot as discussing together with her. I imply, she’s his spouse, so all of that is bizarre as hell.

Hell, I do not understand how Hailey is meant to course of any of this. For the story and character’s sake, it is one thing that begs to be explored — the abandonment scars listed here are astronomical.

However I can not say that I am excited to see that facet of the season unfold, regardless that it’s a necessity. Halstead is gone now, and I can not say I am in a greater place to grasp Upstead, the place this leaves them, and why they pushed so laborious to marry them off if it ended up like this.

And are we supposed to carry out for some Pricey John letter down the highway? It is just like the Gabby/Casey state of affairs and the Casey/Brett state of affairs on Chicago Fireplace.

I do not know what to make of Halstead’s last scene with Voight both. He sounded confused himself. He needs to be Voight, so he has to depart.

The 2 of them have an advanced relationship, they usually turned the Boy Scout, Voight’s Keeper bit on its head with these phrases. It felt extra true to Hailey than to Halstead.

However Halstead is gone, and Voight has misplaced one other particular person he respects and cares about, so the theme stays that Voight retains shedding his folks.

If the weirdness round this serving as an exit weren’t so outstanding, this is able to’ve been a rattling good episode.

Sarcastically, this was essentially the most attention-grabbing Halstead has been in years, and that is as a result of they gave Jesse Lee Soffer extra to do. It is a pity they gave him all this materials for his last installment. He actually delivered.

That opening montage with the nervous tapping of the ring finger and the rising distance between Halstead and Hailey was fantastically shot and directed.

The motion on the pharmacy was pulse-pounding, and so was Halstead’s time in that warehouse. When he repeatedly stabbed Watts, my jaw was on the ground in shock.

And you could possibly inform that Halstead had checked out and was in shock for a bit, which felt like a short callback to his long-abandoned PTSD, and it made me want that these little issues had been explored extra through the years.

Halstead crossed all forms of strains with this case, however he was dedicated to it the second he entered that pharmacy. His immediate reference to Lenny added that private ingredient that makes a case good.

Halstead: I assumed you hated lengthy goodbyes.
Voight: You might have any job you need within the division. You do not want me. You are previous that. When you do not need to be me…
Halstead: No, it is worse than that. I do. I do need to be you. However it’s such as you at all times informed me. I am not, and I should not attempt.

Halstead went off the deep finish just a few instances, and everybody observed it. His no-knock entries into the meth-head home, the deal he could not ship on whereas interrogating him, the selection to depart issues out from Voight — all of it was intense.

Sarcastically, it did not really feel as out of character as it could appear to some followers as a result of we have seen how Halstead will get when he is passionate a couple of case earlier than, the way it can cloud his judgment, and the way he can bend the foundations.

He simply took it up just a few notches. It was certain to land him in some type of bother. Hailey tried to be his voice of cause your entire time, however she could not get via to him.

However it’s like they’ve all been via and achieved too many issues to drag one another’s card, and perhaps that is on the core of the issue.

It is laborious for Hailey to play an ethical compass when he is aware of what she’s achieved and might’t push that out of his thoughts. In fact, he’d go to the lengths he did to guard Lenny after his bond with him.

It was a cycle that needed to break. Halstead ended up in the identical state of affairs that required Voight and Hailey to develop cowl tales to guard him from his actions.

They could not hold taking place that route time and again. Understandably, he needed to put an finish to it. Whereas he nonetheless did not get to personal his actions due to the Chief, he obtained to give up on his phrases and go into one thing he felt suited him higher. Lenny’s phrases about how he did the precise factor when it counted caught with him.

Halstead placing an finish to that cycle is noble, and it stays true to him because the Boy Scout, even when a lot of the opposite stuff was wonky. Halstead felt so misplaced, and I want there was extra buildup or a deeper dive into that as a result of it might have been much more compelling with time.

Halstead: We’re doing it once more.
Voight: What?
Halstead: We’re doing it once more.
Voight: Hear, we do not have quite a lot of time. Now give me the knife.
Halstead: What the hell am I doing?

It is no query that Halstead’s absence will go away a void within the collection.

Over to you, Chicago PD Fanatics. How did you’re feeling about Halstead’s departure? Hold forth beneath!

If you wish to relive the most effective Halstead moments, you possibly can watch Chicago PD on-line right here by way of TV Fanatic.

Jasmine Blu is a senior workers author for TV Fanatic. Observe her on Twitter.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments